AAcquired
← All episodes
03 February 2019

ARM & SoftBank

2Frameworks
11Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster24:00

Why Better Processor Technology Couldn’t Beat Wintel

ARM-powered Archimedes machines did not defeat IBM-compatible PCs despite their processor advantages. DOS, Windows, and essential business applications were tied to x86, showing that ecosystem compatibility and software network effects can outweigh superior underlying technology.

  • DOS and Windows ran on Intel’s x86 architecture
  • Business applications followed the dominant operating-system platform
  • Porting software across instruction sets was exceptionally difficult
  • Technical superiority alone could not overcome the Wintel ecosystem

“it was fundamentally better technology, but because of the duopoly between the Wintel duopoly between Microsoft and Intel, it's almost like nobody really cared.”

David Rosenthal · 25:00

“However, basically nothing would run on it”

Ben Gilbert · 26:30
#wintel#network effects#software#platforms

Explainer· 2

Explainer15:00

Why RISC Beat Complexity with an 80/20 Tradeoff

The hosts contrast Intel’s complex instruction set architecture with Acorn’s reduced instruction set design. ARM omitted less-common instructions and optimized frequently used operations for fast execution, producing strong real-world performance with far fewer transistors and lower power consumption.

  • An instruction set is the language executed by a processor
  • CISC supports numerous complex and variable operations in hardware
  • RISC reduces complexity and optimizes common instructions
  • ARM used roughly 30,000 transistors versus about 134,000 in Intel’s 286
  • Fewer transistors reduced cost and power requirements

“The instruction set architecture you can think about as sort of the language of a chip.”

Ben Gilbert · 16:30

“they were uh they only could do about 80% of the instructions that CISC could do, but they did those instructions, they executed them much,…”

David Rosenthal · 20:30
#risc#cisc#processors#computer architecture
Explainer1:11:30

How SoftBank Assembled the Cash to Buy ARM

SoftBank financed the ARM acquisition by combining major asset sales with substantial borrowing. It sold stakes in Alibaba and Supercell and added a $9 billion loan, while favorable post-Brexit currency movements made the British target comparatively cheaper in yen and dollars.

  • SoftBank sold $10 billion of Alibaba shares
  • It sold $7 billion of Supercell shares
  • It borrowed another $9 billion
  • The weakened pound affected the acquisition economics
  • The financing foreshadowed the appeal of using a large external investment fund

“Where the cash came in from was they sold $10 billion of Alibaba shares and $7 billion of Supercell shares, plus they took a $9…”

Ben Gilbert · 1:12:00

“It was just that before the vision fund, the only way you had to invest through SoftBank balance sheet.”

David Rosenthal · 1:06:00
#deal financing#softbank#alibaba#brexit

Story· 6

Story06:00

How the BBC Micro Created Britain’s Computer Generation

The BBC and the UK government launched a national computer-literacy initiative and selected Acorn Computers to build machines for schools. The BBC Micro sold more than 1.5 million units, giving a generation of British children early access to personal computing and providing the foundation from which ARM would eventually emerge.

  • The BBC combined television education with computers placed in schools
  • Acorn won the government contract and shipped the BBC Micro from 1981
  • More than 1.5 million units were sold, primarily in the UK
  • The program gave Acorn scale and a prominent place in British computing

“But the cornerstone and the really cool ambitious thing that they're doing is they want to put new microcomputers, true like personal computers for the…”

David Rosenthal · 06:30

“They end up selling over one and a half million units, almost all in the UK”

David Rosenthal · 08:30
#acorn#bbc micro#computer history#education
Story12:00

Intel’s Rejection Pushed Acorn to Invent Its Own Processor

Acorn wanted Intel’s forthcoming processor for its professional Archimedes computer, but Intel declined to supply the small Cambridge company. With few alternatives, Acorn assigned its own engineers to develop a competitive processor, turning a supplier rejection into a pivotal act of vertical innovation.

  • Acorn needed more performance than its existing 8-bit processor offered
  • Intel refused Acorn access to its new processor
  • Acorn possessed unusually strong Cambridge engineering talent
  • The rejection prompted Acorn to build its own microprocessor

“Intel makes one of the worst business decisions in history in all of business history and says no.”

David Rosenthal · 12:30

“Maybe we can just build our own microprocessor.”

David Rosenthal · 14:00
#intel#acorn#arm#innovation
Story28:00

The Accidental Discovery That Made ARM Perfect for Mobile

ARM’s engineers initially reduced transistor count to lower manufacturing costs, not to create a mobile processor. Prototype processors then appeared to operate without a dedicated CPU power line, revealing that the architecture consumed dramatically less electricity and opening a path toward battery-powered computing.

  • Low cost was the original design objective
  • Prototype CPUs functioned without a dedicated processor power supply
  • Fewer transistors sharply reduced electricity requirements
  • Low power became a decisive advantage for PDAs and phones

“It turned out they sometimes would function even without a power supply.”

David Rosenthal · 28:00

“it needed much less electricity and power to be able to run even at really high performance.”

David Rosenthal · 29:00
#low power#mobile computing#arm#engineering
Story32:00

Apple’s Newton Project Created ARM as a Standalone Company

Apple needed a low-power processor for the Newton but could not comfortably license critical technology from a direct computer competitor. Apple, Acorn, Olivetti, and VLSI therefore spun Acorn’s processor group into ARM, with Apple investing $1.5 million for a 43% stake and collaborating on the ARM610.

  • Apple discovered Acorn’s processor through VLSI
  • Competitive concerns made a conventional Acorn license unattractive
  • The parties created ARM as an independent company within roughly six weeks
  • Apple received 43% for a $1.5 million investment
  • The ARM610 powered the Apple Newton

“Within like six weeks of when uh when they get together, they've spun out the company into a new division, a new to new totally…”

David Rosenthal · 34:30

“Apple brings the money, they get 43% of the company for one and a half million dollars.”

David Rosenthal · 35:00
#apple#newton#arm#spinout
Story50:30

How ARM Stock Proceeds Helped Save Apple from Bankruptcy

Apple retained its ARM stake until ARM’s 1998 IPO, when Apple itself was bleeding cash and facing a serious financial crisis. By gradually selling ARM shares during the technology boom, Apple realized $792 million in profit that helped keep the company operating while Steve Jobs rebuilt its product line.

  • ARM listed in London and on Nasdaq in 1998
  • Apple still held shares from its original investment
  • Apple sold the position gradually as ARM’s price increased
  • The sales produced $792 million in profit
  • That cash supported Apple during its near-bankruptcy period

“The ARM IPO, had it not happened, very likely Apple would have gone bankrupt.”

David Rosenthal · 51:00

“They make 792 million dollars in profit from selling their ARM stock over the next couple of years.”

David Rosenthal · 51:30
#apple#arm ipo#corporate finance#turnaround
Story1:01:00

The Yacht, Private Jets, and Masa Son’s $32 Billion ARM Offer

After questioning ARM CEO Simon Segars at a dinner, Masayoshi Son demanded an immediate meeting with Segars and chairman Stuart Chambers, who was vacationing on a yacht in Turkey. Son flew the participants to a private restaurant near the marina and presented a $32 billion offer at a large premium, leading to an extraordinarily rapid agreement.

  • Masa first investigated ARM at a Woodside dinner
  • He summoned ARM’s CEO and chairman to Turkey
  • Private jets brought the parties together near Chambers’ yacht
  • SoftBank offered $32 billion at roughly a 43% premium
  • ARM’s board approved and announced the transaction within two weeks

“Masa buys out an entire restaurant with like a view overlooking the marina.”

David Rosenthal · 1:04:00

“I want to buy you guys, and I'm gonna offer you 32 billion dollars”

David Rosenthal · 1:04:00
#softbank#masayoshi son#acquisition#arm

Q&A· 1

Q&A1:19:00

The Bull and Bear Cases for SoftBank’s ARM Bet

The bull case is that ambient computing puts ARM-based processors into hundreds of devices around each person, multiplying royalties across a vast installed base. The bear case is that ARM captures only a tiny fraction of downstream value, low-cost embedded chips produce minimal royalties, or a new architecture eventually displaces ARM before the purchase price earns an adequate return.

  • Ambient computing could multiply the number of processors per person
  • SoftBank paid $32 billion while ARM generated under $2 billion in annual revenue
  • Cheaper devices may generate smaller royalties per unit
  • Most value may accrue to integrated device manufacturers rather than ARM
  • Architectural displacement remains a long-term risk

“There's a very reasonable chance that we have hundreds of of ARM chips that we're interacting with over the course of the day.”

Ben Gilbert · 1:20:00

“the company, while a great company and a foundational technology company actually can't command that much of the value creation uh going forward from computing”

David Rosenthal · 1:24:00
#valuation#ambient computing#arm#investment thesis

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway1:13:00

Why ARM Needed a Deep-Pocketed but Neutral Owner

ARM’s position as a common technology supplier made many obvious strategic buyers dangerous. An acquisition by Apple, Qualcomm, or another ecosystem participant could alarm rivals and reduce ARM’s value, whereas SoftBank had enough capital to fund research without directly controlling a competing processor or device platform.

  • ARM supplies companies that compete directly with one another
  • Ownership by a major customer could undermine ecosystem trust
  • Few neutral buyers could raise approximately $30 billion
  • SoftBank could fund aggressive growth without absorbing ARM into a competing product line
  • ARM remained an independent SoftBank division

“if you sold to Apple, then you know, Qualcomm's freaking out that they're not gonna have access to to their core technology anymore.”

Ben Gilbert · 1:13:00

“I I would say it's it's fortunate and and value creating for the world that it landed where it did.”

Ben Gilbert · 1:13:30
#platform neutrality#softbank#ecosystems#m&a