Why Shipping an Embarrassing MVP Can Be the Wrong Move
Rahul argues that the famous advice to launch before a product feels ready depends on market structure. A rough product can win when it creates a new market or gains compounding network effects, but an incumbent challenger must already clear the quality bar set by strong alternatives.
- Email clients are technically complex and can take years to build well.
- Superhuman competed against established products rather than a missing alternative.
- New-market products can deliver value despite rough early execution.
- Network effects reward even small first-mover advantages.
- Existing-market productivity products must meet a much higher initial quality threshold.
“I think his advice applies most to startups that are creating new markets, and especially to startups that have network effects.”
“But for a startup like Superhuman in an existing market. Exactly, where the alternative product is Gmail, and without an explicit network effect built into…”